A True Story About Losing Twice
Most convenience store owners don’t realize they are carrying a hidden liability inside their portfolio — one that quietly erodes profitability, limits growth, and ultimately reduces the value of their business.
The issue is not market conditions. It’s not competition. And it’s not a temporary disruption. It’s underperforming stores.
After working with convenience store operators for decades, one pattern continues to surface: Many owners are operating locations that consistently lose money — and they continue to do so year after year.
THE $1 MILLION MISTAKE
Here is a real-world true story I encountered.
Evan was an operator who had more than 30 locations and asked me to do a market valuation of what his stores were worth. During the analysis, it became clear that nearly one-third of the stores were unprofitable. Not marginally — these locations were collectively losing over $1 million annually.
More importantly, this wasn’t a short-term issue. The losses had been ongoing for years.
When I presented Evan with the data, he acknowledged the problem but chose not to take action. What I learned was this type of behavior was more common that I had realized.
WHY OWNERS HOLD ON TO LOSING STORES
Underperforming stores often remain in a portfolio for reasons that have little to do with sound business strategy:
- Optimism that performance will improve
- Emotional attachment to a location (it was the family’s first store)
- Reluctance to admit a past investment was a mistake
- Fear of making a difficult decision
- Helps to contribute to corporate overhead
- Do not want to face letting employees go (we call this letting the inmates run the asylum)
However, the numbers do not change based on intention.
If a store is not profitable over a sustained period and not breaking even — it is actively draining capital from your business. The true cost of keeping a losing store open is only the beginning because underperforming stores create a ripple effect across your entire operation.
- Capital Drain
Every dollar lost in a weak store is a dollar that cannot be reinvested into high-performing locations, acquisitions, or upgrades. - Management Distraction
Time and energy spent trying to “fix” a weak store reduces your ability to optimize your best-performing assets. Top operators focus on scaling success, not subsidizing failure. - Increased Operational Risk
Every store carries exposure:
- Employee theft (cash, inventory, or time)
- Workplace injuries and rising workers’ compensation costs
- Compliance and operational oversight requirements
A losing store multiplies these risks without delivering a return.
- Customer and Legal Liability
Even unprofitable stores face the same exposure to customer incidents, including slip-and-fall claims and liability issues that can increase insurance premiums. - Environmental Exposure
For fuel operators, environmental risk is significant. Leaks, spills, or compliance failures can result in substantial financial and legal consequences.Maintaining an unprofitable location increases unnecessary exposure.
- Brand Degradation
Customers notice the difference between strong and weak locations. Underperforming stores are often less maintained, understocked, and poorly staffed.This impacts not just that store, but your entire brand.
- Employee Morale and Turnover
Employees recognize when a store is struggling. This leads to disengagement, higher turnover, and difficulty attracting quality staff, further accelerating decline. - Higher Insurance Costs
Insurance premiums, particularly workers’ compensation, are often tied to payroll. Maintaining underperforming stores increases overall exposure and cost. - Reduced Access to Capital
Lenders closely evaluate financial performance. A portfolio with multiple underperforming assets raises concerns about management discipline and risk.This can limit your ability to secure financing for expansion or improvements.
- Lower Business Valuation
Perhaps the most significant long-term impact: Underperforming stores reduce the overall value of your business.Buyers do not overlook weak assets — they discount them
THE COMPOUNDING EFFECT
In the case referenced earlier, Evan continued to run his underperforming stores for over a decade. The result:
- Over $10 million dollars was lost in ongoing operations.
- There was significant reduction in final sale value.
In many cases, the cumulative losses from holding onto weak stores equal — or exceed — the value gained from eventually selling the business. (Evan lost as much money as he was paid when we sold the stores.)
High-performing operators approach their portfolio differently because they know:
- Not every store is worth saving.
- They can take the money from the sale of the underperforming store and acquire or build a new store.
One of the most effective principles in this industry is simple:
Work on making your best stores great — not trying to make your bad stores good.
If you currently own multiple locations, now is the time to take a disciplined, objective look at your portfolio.
Ask yourself:
- Which stores are consistently underperforming?
- How long have they been unprofitable?
- What is the true cost of continuing to operate them?
- How is this impacting your overall valuation?
- If there is no upside in operating the store, why are you keeping it?
In many cases, underperforming stores still have value, just not to the current owner.
Through strategic repositioning, restructuring, or a targeted sale, these assets can be converted from a liability into liquidity.
The key is timing and execution.
If you own multiple convenience stores and are unsure how your portfolio would truly perform in today’s market, a professional valuation can provide clarity.
At American Business Brokers & Advisors, we specialize in helping convenience store owners:
- Identify underperforming assets
- Improve overall portfolio performance
- Maximize business valuation
- Execute strategic exits
A confidential, no-obligation portfolio review can often uncover opportunities worth hundreds of thousands — or even millions — of dollars.
REQUEST A CONFIDENTIAL PORTFOLIO REVIEW
If you are considering selling, restructuring, or simply want a clearer picture of your business value, we invite you to start with a confidential and professional evaluation.
The most successful operators are not those who avoid difficult decisions — they are the ones who make them early.
The question is not whether you can afford to hold on to a losing store.
It’s whether you can afford not to. Don’t be an Evan and lose twice.




